Whatever
Happened to the Quiz Kids?
A Remembrance of Things Past
One night, when I was a teenager back in the forties,
I was listening to "The Quiz Kids" on the radio when the announcer
asked 6-year-old Joel Kupperman to calculate how many seconds there are
in a year. There was a stretching silence for, perhaps, 30 or 40 seconds.
Finally, Joel spoke up and, in a childish drawl, said, "31,536,000."
The announcer started to say, "That's very good, Jo--", but Joel
interrupted him, and they tripped over each other for a second. Finally,
Joel managed to get the floor, and said, "31,536,360. I added in leap
year."
That brought down the house.
Ruth Feldman's
book devotes an entire chapter to Joel Kupperman. Joel didn't begin to walk
and talk until he was 18 months old(!) At 4, he could total his mother's
grocery bill faster than an adding machine. Interestingly enough, he and
his engineer-father had a 15-minute numbers workout before breakfast every
morning. The book's author, the former 'Ruthie Duskin', who also had a childhood
I. Q. of 200+, writes,
'His I. Q. was above 200, and his mental development
was the highest that ever had been tested in the twenty-five years of child
study by the Chicago public schools. By six, he was reading eighth grade
history books* and had been skipped into second grade; his parents were
loath to push him any faster.'
And listen to this:
'Engaging Joel in conversation,' Fred Allen once
said, 'is not unlike talking to a vine. Every time you turn around, the
vine has grown out of earshot. You say something, and the next thing you
know, he has clambered up your vest front and down your spine.' (Joel said
he was sorry for Allen because the comedian was "awfully dumb"
about numbers. The two kept up a correspondence, and at Allen's request.
the boy sent him the next tooth he lost. Allen wrote back that he was keeping
it on his desk and leaving, "little bits of candy and meat around in
case the tooth gets hungry.')
Another Kuppermanism -
"That wath only a thynopthith. My muvver told
me I've been talking too much."
Joel Kupperman became a philosophy professor at
the University of Connecticut. He would be 64 by now.
Many of the Quiz Kids were ambivalent, if not downright
negative about their stints on the Quiz Kids program. Like the "Termites",
by and large, they ended up prosperous and successful as adults. James Watson
was the Nobel Prize-winner of the group. It's important to realize that
when their childhood ratio I. Q.'s are converted to deviation I. Q.'s, they
were very bright but of course, not as extraordinary as those childhood
ratio I. Q.'s would have suggested. The average I. Q. Of the ~600 children
who participated in the original show over its 12-year history was about
160, corresponding to a deviation I. Q. of 150, and an expected frequency
of occurrence (for an I. Q. of 150 and above) of about 1 in 1,100. Factoring
in whatever regression to the mean may have occurred as they grew into adulthood,
and whatever "digression from the mean" may have occurred with
other "late-blooming" children in the Chicago area who might have
overtaken them in adulthood, perhaps their accomplishments were about what
might be expected in such a group."
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
* One mother of a three-and-a-half year-old reported a year-and-a-half ago
in a plaintive call for help that her daughter had been tested as reading
at 5th-grade level. And of course, Michael (Kearney) started high school
at 5.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
I was thinking about how remarkable that was. I'm wondering
what ever became of the children on that program. Harold Brown served as
the Department of Defense (Deputy?) Director for Research and Engineering
(DDR&E), which, I believe, may be DoD's highest technical post. Vanessa
Brown had a movie contract, but didn't become a household name. (Few do.)
She died of cancer in 1999. Gerard Darrow was another long-standing participant
on "The Quiz Kids". As I remember it, the children were drawn
largely, if not entirely from the Chicago area, although there were occasional
guest stars from other locales.
Today's hero is Joe S., who noted that in reciting
Joel Kupperman's answer to the question, "How many seconds are there
in a year?", I added 3,600 seconds for the six extra hours that correct
for leap years, instead of the correct 360 seconds. Thanks, Joe. Joe also
mentioned that he thinks that Dr. James Watson, of Crick and Watson fame,
was also a Quiz Kid. He thinks Dr. Watson received his Ph. D. at 23. Does
anyone have any information concerning that question?
Jack Lucal, James Watson, Ruth
Duskin, Margaret Merrick, Claude Brenner |
Gerard Darrow, Claude
Brenner, Richard Williams, Margaret Merrick, Joel Kupperman, David Prochaska,
Ruth Duskin, Harve Fischman, with Chico Marx |


And Now, the Answers:
10-28-2000: Joe S. has furnished further information regarding Dr. Watson's
stint on the Quiz
Kids program. Born in Chicago in 1928, James Watson received his
B. S. degree from the University of Chicago at the age of 19, and his Ph.
D. from Indiana University at 22. From there, he went to Copenhagen, Cambridge,
and Caltech on post-doctoral fellowships, and joined the Harvard faculty
at the age of 27.
I then ran a search on "Quiz
Kids" and guess what I found? Me!
Twice! It is to cringe!:Of all the people who are unworthy of being recognized
as a Quiz Kid, I'm the most unworthy. I flunked out. One of the nemeses
(the only one I can remember) was the question, "If the Aurora Borealis
is the name of the Northern Lights, what is the name of the Southern Lights?"
I'm sure I must have stood there and stared at the floor. The answer is,
"the Aurora Australis." I suppose that you were supposed to realize
that "Aurora" was the goddess of the dawn, and "Boreas"
was the god of the north wind, so "Aurora Borealis" means "dawn
in the north". Then you were supposed to know that Australis was the
god of the south wind (I think), so "dawn in the south" would
be "Aurora Australis". But I didn't say that. I was too busy staring
at the floor. It's strange how the search engine picked up that reference,
and yet didn't home in on what I know must be legion out there. There were
many stars like Gerard who were on the Quiz Kids for years, and whose names
should spring to the fore in a search like this.
Here's what else
I found (at "Ask
Me"):
"David
Buswell gave this response on 6/12/2000:
"'Quiz Kids' ran for about 10 years on radio and
briefly on early TV. The emcee was Joe Kelly and the show was created by
Lou Cowan (who later produced TV's $64,000 Question and was disgraced by
the rigging scandals) and emanated from Chicago. Over the years there were
hundreds of kids who were temporarily on the show and their IQ's averaged
about 160 or so. One tested at over
200 (Ruthie
Duskin).
"But in addition to the transients, there were
several regulars including Joel Kupperman was certainly the most famous
and he lasted 10 years. He graduated from the University of Chicago and
is a PhD who has taught as a philosophy professor at Chicago and Cambridge
University. He wrote a book entitled "Fundamentals of Logic and Ethical
Knowledge." He shuns all interviews about his days on Quiz Kids and
has never gone to any of the show's reunions. He is called by his peers
on the show "the Garbo of the group." Two other alums of the program
became semi-well known. One was Vanessa
Brown who became a minor TV and film actress and James
Watson who won a Nobel Prize in medicine."
"On a radio game show, The Quiz Kids, Dr. Glenn
Seaborg was a guest questioner when the host turned the tables and allowed
the children to question him. One student asked Seaborg if he had discovered
any new elements. Though the announcement was scheduled for the next day,
Seaborg answered, " Yes. Recently there have been two new elements
discovered, elements with atomic numbers 95 and 96." The program ended
with a commercial, making this the first and only time that the announcement
of the discovery of new elements was sponsored by Alka-Seltzer."
I'm particularly interested in this because,
(1) In 1954, my deceased wife, Ruth, graduated from Shimer College (a subsidiary
of the University of Chicago) during the week of her 20th birthday. (She
didn't win a Nobel Prize.) The U. of C. was operating the Robert Maynard
Hutchens Classics program for gifted students, in which the students could
pass the 14 year-long courses solely by examination credit.
(2) Drs. Crick and Watson were cited as examples of Nobel Laureates who
had IQs below 120, but who made it through pluck, luck, and fortitude. Ha!
Instead they would seem to be examples of the advantages of a high IQ in
making it big in the sciences.
Ruth
Duskin Feldman became
an educator in the Chicago area, writing a book entitled, "What
Ever Happened to the Quiz Kids?". (I bought a copy of the book today,
and will report on it here after it arrives.) She has been one of three
authors co-authoring the widely used textbook, "A Child's World"
(McGraw Hill), now in its 8th edition. She has also written four other books,
including, "Perils and Profits of Growing Up Gifted".
Bobby Ray
Inman became an admiral and the deputy director fo the CIA.
Mark Mullins,
after appearing on the Quiz Kids between the ages of 6 and 10, and graduating
from Harvard, became an Episcopal priest, and served as the headmaster of
the prestigious St. Albans prep school in Washington, D. C. (Albert Gore,
III, is a student there.)
Louis
Edward Sissman has been hailed as one of the outstanding poets of
the 20th century.
Robert
Easton is a movie director, having directed such movies as "the
Red Badge of Courage" and "Star Trek VI".
Alan Kay
was one of the masterminds behind Xerox' Parc, and Apple Computer.
More material is presented below:
"Stressing
the Smart Kids"
Life Magazine, August
5
Roby
Kesler (wrote book "The Quiz Kids")
Quiz Kids Radio
Programs
More
Quiz Kid Radio Programs
Quiz
Kids on TV
Quiz
Kids Movie
Sheila Conlon and Bob Burke
One footnote:
Ms. Feldman mentions that there were four Quiz Kids who tested above I.
Q. 200 as children. The greater Chicago area would have had, probably, between
4,500,000 and 6,000,000 inhabitants in the 1940's. The show accepted children
from age 4 to age 16 from 1940 to 1952. That would have afforded a total
Chicago-based sampling cohort of, perhaps, 1,500,000 to 2,000,000 children
(not including children from other cities who sometimes appeared on the
show) over the program's tenure. One I. Q. of 200+ per 500,000 people would
have agreed fairly well with the observed numbers. (It's worth noting that
in the Terman Study, such high I. Q. scores occurred slightly more often
than a log-normal distribution would predict, but the Terman sample was
urban, rather than urban and rural, and 35% of the children's parents were
professionals compared with, on average, 3% professionals in the general
population of that day.)
Looking further into Miraca Gross' book:
She explains that she used the Stanford Binet Forms L
& M to obtain mental ages for her children, but she doesn't mention
which revision of the SB she used except to say that it wasn't Revision
IV. Also, the highest IQ that she lists in her tables is 175+, but this
is for the four children who have tested elsewhere at 200 or above on the
SB. So I'm not sure just what her scores mean.
I figured it out! It turns out that only three of the above
four children, Ian, Adrian, and Chris, had IQs at the 200+ level. The fourth,
Hadley, had a 178 IQ, but all four are listed as 175+. So the other 11 children
had ratio IQs between 160 and 174. Interestingly enough, there were 1,700,000
children who were within the age range and the geographical area from which
Dr. Gross identified only 40 children with IQs of 160 or above. The three
children with IQs of 200+ are about what we'd expect out of 1,700,000 children,
corresponding to about 1 in 567,000, compared to the 1 in 500,000 that a
log-normal model would predict. However, there should have been about 1,700
children with ratio IQs of 160 or above (deviation IQs of 150 or above),
and Dr. Gross only found 40. She explains that IQ testing isn't practiced
in the schools in Australia. She explains that Australia is a very egalitarian,
anti-intellectual, frontier society, perhaps like the U. S. in the days
of the Old West. Consequently, she was dependent upon teacher selection
to identify children for individual testing.
The bottom line is that her distribution is bimodal,
with 3 children at 200 or 200+, and 12 children averaging in the upper 160's.
And yet the median age to begin reading was 2 years 7 months, compared to
a median age of a little above 3 for Leta Hollingsworth's children with
an average IQ of about 190.
In short, it's consistent with, although, of course,
it doesn't prove that today's children are smarter than they were in the
1930's (when I was a puppy).
My. friend, Bob Park,
in Sydney, says that he has seen Dr. Gross on TV in Australia, and talked
with her over the phone. Dr. Gross is diminutive, and has a Scottish brogue.
Bob has also met "Daniel". 'Daniel's" childhood IQ was measured
at 198. Daniel started university at 13 or 14, is now about 17, and is "very
nice, and very, very smart". (It's interesting when your friend knows
someone written up in books like "Exceptionally Gifted Children".)
A few days ago, I wrote, "Ruth
Duskin Feldman became
an educator in the Chicago area, writing a book entitled, "What
Ever Happened to the Quiz Kids?". (I bought a copy of the book today,
and will report on it here after it arrives.)"
Well, it arrived, I've skimmed it, and its contents
are fascinating. I'm intrigued with what has become of the Quiz Kids and
with their attitudes regarding their stints as Quiz Kids celebrities. They've
met with varying degrees of success and recognition, ranging from Noebl
Prize winner James Watson to the deceased Gerard Darrow. I'll try to write
this up as soon as I have a chance.