Are My
"Brain-Boosting" Experiments Paying Off?
July 12, 2009
July 12th Update:
I've now been on brain-boosting supplements for more than a week, and have been
chipping away at the dual n-back training program that's supposed to raise your
IQ. How much? the original study cut off after 19 half-hour training sessions,
and as of that end-point, there didn't seem to be any leveling off of the rates
of rise of the trainees scores. I've looked, but haven't found anything yet that
points toward follow-on studies.
Here's a testimonial for Mind Sparke Brain Fitness Pro™:
Brain Fitness Pro Increased My IQ Score 12 Points In 19 Days ...
The before-and-after IQ tests that the subject used were free online IQ tests
rather than official, formally validated IQ tests. Here are comments from "Shaun
Luttin") who has worked seriously at mastering the dual n-back training
program. This also includes a report concerning "Lloyd" in Florida
who, after being rejected by Mensa (Iq >= 130), registered 151 on the
WAIS-III after three months of Brain Fitness training. (This is remarkable if
it's really representative of what can happen. The WAIS-III, unlike the Raven
Progressive Matrices or the BOMAT, tests crystallized intelligence as well as
fluid intelligence.) Of course, extraordinary claims require extraordinary
proof.
Here's another interesting dual
n-back thread. And here's a report from yesterday, July 11th: Working-Memory Training Report - martin - Session 175.,
and this: Improvements in n-back scores.
Getting back to brain-boosting supplements, it's hard to
detect an escalation in IQ when you're reading "Hansel and Gretel" to
your toddler, or blowing the debris off the driveway, but I'm cognizant of a
high level of verbal fluency that may be have been appreciably improved. (It's
hard to tell because I haven't been involved over this past week in any writing
that has given rein to verbal proficiency.)
July 5th Update:
It seems to me that my brain-boosting
experiment really is producing a ponderable effect. My verbal fluency
is quite high, and I'm remembering names and trivia that seem to be
beyond what I might otherwise expect. I'll be upping my dose of
Advanced Orthomolecular Research' Ortho Mind 1.0. AOR states
that their product exhibits a U-shaped response curve, and recommends
increasing one's dosage gradually to assess one's optimum
dosage.
July 4th:
I
don't really know. Without before-and-after testing, how can you
tell? Any claims that "a mental fog will lift and you'll feel
more alive" is, at least in my experience so far, pure hype. And
it's not as though most of us don't know what its like to find
ourselves in a mental fog. It happens on "blah" morning
when we just can't seem to get started, like, maybe, the first day
back to work after we've been on vacation, or the day after we've
engaged in unaccustomed physical exercise. Drinking a strong cup or
two of coffee may banish the "blahs", at least temporarily.
But it's my fantasy that if you woke up tomorrow and found that your
IQ were 30 points higher than it is today, you wouldn't immediately
notice the difference. I suspect that having a higher IQ doesn't
cause us to experience the world more vividly. I suspect that
sensitivity to one's environment has to do with one's age, and with
the novelty of experiences. I could imagine that your additional 30
points of IQ might manifest itself only when you tackled a new
problem, or began to speak or write, and found alternative words and
phrases rolling trippingly off your tongue or keyboard.
My personal notion is that alertness and photographic recall is part
of the armamentarium of a young mammal, particularly in the absence
of speech. The young mammal must learn at a very rapid rate, and must
retain what it learns. This need to record experiences in non-verbal
terms would seem to me to call for alertness and eidetic recall in
children, and would explain why a photographic memory tends to fade
away when a person reaches adulthood.
Anyway,
these are my speculations.
That having been
said, it seems as though my thinking, my verbal fluency, and my
memory have improved somewhat, but the changes are subtle, and
highly subjective. I could be experiencing a placebo effect. Also,
it's possible that nootropic effects could require more time to come
to full fruition.